Mel Gibson, in the 1990 film
version of Hamlet, speaks in a slow and deliberate monotone, explains his
sorrow to his mother, and allows her to grope him; this delivery brings to foray Hamlet’s
sadness, but downplays his revulsion and anger. Gibson’s very first line, “a
little more than kin and less than kind” illustrates this point perfectly.
Gibson elongates, spaces-out,
and enunciates the words in this first line to such an extent that the viewer
stops thinking about the meanings of the words. Instead, one thinks of how
morose he must be to be so dilatory, how well he enunciates in a fake British
accent, and of when the scene will move on. This shift of focus detracts from
the sarcasm, rage, repugnance, sass, and emotion Hamlet’s lines would otherwise
express. Later in the scene, when Hamlet and Gertrude are left alone, Hamlet
explains to Gertrude how his depression is not just an act, and in doing so
shows viewers his seething emotions regarding his father’s murder and his
mother’s hasty and incestuous marriage (and his sorrow, of course). But this is
not present in the Gibson version. He speaks slowly, deliberately, and
genuinely attempts to explain his emotions to his mother as an equal. Though it
illuminates Hamlet’s anguish and argument, this delivery submerges the angry
sarcasm and moral outrage in a sea of sorrow, sloth, explanations, and mutual
respect (sibilance intentional). And, throughout the scene, Gertrude (actor)
essentially feels Gibson up (need a less colloquial way of saying that), and
Gibson allows it. Although Shakespeare never says it, it is just nonsensical
for hamlet to be okay with his incestuous and betraying mother to fondle him, especially
while he is so dejected and mournful. Maybe he accepts her touching because he is
too sad to refuse, but that does not make up for the fury and moral repulsion
his acting lacks. Mel Gibson’s portrayal of Hamlet (in Act I Scene II) brings
Hamlet’s sorrow to life. But, in doing so, Gibson ignored Hamlet’s outrage
(both moral and vengeful) with his mother and his new father.
this method of posting each paragraph is very good because if something goes wrong and you lose your essay on your computer, its still safe on the internet.
No comments:
Post a Comment